Thad Matta — Record in Overtime Games
19–15
55.9%
win rate
+1.3
avg margin
34
games
Games (34)
| # | Date | Season | School | Opponent | Opp. Conf. | Loc | W/L | Score | Type | Arena |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2000-12-06 | 2000–01 | Butler | Indiana State | Missouri Valley | Away | L | 88–90 OT | Regular | Hulman Center |
| 2 | 2001-02-15 | 2000–01 | Butler | Milwaukee | Midwestern Collegiate | Home | W | 80–75 OT | Regular | Hinkle Fieldhouse |
| 3 | 2002-03-07 | 2001–02 | #24 Xavier | Massachusetts | A10 | Neutral | W | 65–59 OT | Conf. Tourn. | The Spectrum |
| 4 | 2003-02-26 | 2002–03 | #13 Xavier | Duquesne | A10 | Away | W | 80–78 OT | Regular | UPMC Cooper Fieldhouse |
| 5 | 2003-03-05 | 2002–03 | #11 Xavier | Saint Joseph's | A10 | Away | W | 88–80 OT | Regular | Hagan Arena |
| 6 | 2003-11-29 | 2003–04 | Xavier | Indiana | B10 | Neutral | L | 77–80 OT | Regular | Gainbridge Fieldhouse |
| 7 | 2004-11-24 | 2004–05 | Ohio State | Creighton | Missouri Valley | Neutral | L | 63–65 OT | Regular | Municipal Auditorium |
| 8 | 2005-01-15 | 2004–05 | Ohio State | Louisiana State | SEC | Away | L | 101–113 2OT | Regular | Maravich Assembly Center |
| 9 | 2005-01-19 | 2004–05 | Ohio State | Minnesota | B10 | Home | L | 56–60 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 10 | 2005-11-22 | 2005–06 | Ohio State | Butler | Horizon | Home | W | 79–69 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 11 | 2006-01-15 | 2005–06 | #19 Ohio State | #14 Michigan State | B10 | Home | L | 59–62 2OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 12 | 2007-03-17 | 2006–07 | #1 Ohio State | Xavier | A10 | Neutral | W | 78–71 OT | NCAA | Rupp Arena |
| 13 | 2008-03-04 | 2007–08 | Ohio State | #15 Purdue | B10 | Home | W | 80–77 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 14 | 2009-02-03 | 2008–09 | #24 Ohio State | #12 Purdue | B10 | Home | W | 80–72 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 15 | 2009-03-20 | 2008–09 | #24 Ohio State | Siena | MAAC | Neutral | L | 72–74 2OT | NCAA | University of Dayton Arena |
| 16 | 2010-03-13 | 2009–10 | #5 Ohio State | Illinois | B10 | Neutral | W | 88–81 2OT | Conf. Tourn. | Gainbridge Fieldhouse |
| 17 | 2011-03-11 | 2010–11 | #1 Ohio State | Northwestern | B10 | Neutral | W | 67–61 OT | Conf. Tourn. | Gainbridge Fieldhouse |
| 18 | 2013-02-05 | 2012–13 | #10 Ohio State | #3 Michigan | B10 | Away | L | 74–76 OT | Regular | Crisler Center |
| 19 | 2014-01-07 | 2013–14 | #3 Ohio State | #5 Michigan State | B10 | Away | L | 68–72 OT | Regular | Breslin Events Center |
| 20 | 2014-01-29 | 2013–14 | #24 Ohio State | Penn State | B10 | Home | L | 70–71 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 21 | 2015-01-06 | 2014–15 | #22 Ohio State | Minnesota | B10 | Away | W | 74–72 OT | Regular | Williams Arena |
| 22 | 2015-03-19 | 2014–15 | #23 Ohio State | #25 Virginia Commonwealth | A10 | Neutral | W | 75–72 OT | NCAA | Moda Center |
| 23 | 2015-11-27 | 2015–16 | Ohio State | Memphis | AAC | Neutral | L | 76–81 OT | Regular | American Airlines Center |
| 24 | 2016-01-28 | 2015–16 | Ohio State | Illinois | B10 | Away | W | 68–63 OT | Regular | State Farm Center |
| 25 | 2016-02-20 | 2015–16 | Ohio State | Nebraska | B10 | Away | W | 65–62 OT | Regular | Pinnacle Bank Arena |
| 26 | 2016-03-15 | 2015–16 | Ohio State | Akron | MAC | Home | W | 72–63 OT | NIT | Value City Arena |
| 27 | 2016-12-06 | 2016–17 | Ohio State | Florida Atlantic | CUSA | Home | L | 77–79 OT | Regular | Value City Arena |
| 28 | 2023-11-30 | 2023–24 | Butler | Texas Tech | B12 | Home | W | 103–95 OT | Regular | Hinkle Fieldhouse |
| 29 | 2023-12-09 | 2023–24 | Butler | California | Pacific 12 | Home | W | 97–90 2OT | Regular | Hinkle Fieldhouse |
| 30 | 2023-12-23 | 2023–24 | Butler | Providence | Big East | Away | L | 75–85 OT | Regular | Amica Mutual Pavilion |
| 31 | 2024-01-27 | 2023–24 | Butler | Villanova | Big East | Home | W | 88–81 2OT | Regular | Hinkle Fieldhouse |
| 32 | 2025-01-21 | 2024–25 | Butler | #19 Connecticut | Big East | Away | L | 78–80 OT | Regular | PeoplesBank Arena |
| 33 | 2025-12-13 | 2025–26 | Butler | Providence | Big East | Home | W | 113–110 2OT | Regular | Hinkle Fieldhouse |
| 34 | 2026-02-04 | 2025–26 | Butler | Providence | Big East | Away | L | 87–97 2OT | Regular | Amica Mutual Pavilion |